Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Jul 20, 2020. It is now read-only.

A VueJS "file list" component that does not work correctly with every browser. Why?

Notifications You must be signed in to change notification settings

klehelley/filepicker-anomaly

Folders and files

NameName
Last commit message
Last commit date

Latest commit

 

History

6 Commits
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Repository files navigation

Filepicker anomaly

This project demonstrates a problem with an implementation of a file list widget, implemented with the help of VueJS, that works with some browsers but not others. To be more precise, clicking the "Add a file" button should trigger the opening of a file picker, but that is not the case with Chrome. And I have no idea why.

This code is a heavily simplified version of what I have to work with. It demonstrates the exact issue I am trying to fix, without success so far...

The issue seems to be related to the way VueJS and Chrome behave when used together for my specific use-case. In the mounted hook used in the file-upload component, the Javascript call to click() seems not to be working correctly (do note that when jQuery is added to the mix, a click event is indeed captured and processed before letting the browser open the file picker... when it does).

Overview

This project is made of 3 separate codebases, with each in a given folder :

  • vuejs-webpack
    • this codebase is the closest to the one I have to fix (though it is already somewhat simplified)
    • this codebase demonstrates the issue
    • this codebase uses .vue files
    • to test the component, make sure you have NodeJS installed and run the following commands to compile the code and start a local server:
      cd vuejs-webpack/
      npm install
      npm run dev
  • vuejs-no-webpack
    • this codebase demonstrates the issue
    • this codebase does not use .vue file and does not require the use of Webpack or NodeJS
    • to test the component, just open the file vuejs-no-webpack/index.html with your favourite browsers
  • no-vuejs
    • this codebase works correctly
    • this codebase only uses vanilla Javascript
    • to test the component, just open the file no-vuejs/index.html with your favourite browsers

How to check the anomaly

Just click on the "Add a file" button to check if it works.

Browsers tested so far

  • Firefox 56/Ubuntu 17.04 : clicking "Add a file" opens a filepicker (may be detected as a pop-up and blocked)
  • Chrome 53/Ubuntu 17.04 : the filepicker never appears
  • Internet Explorer 11/Windows 7 : clicking "Add a file" opens a filepicker
  • Firefox 56/Windows 7 : clicking "Add a file" opens a filepicker (may be detected as a pop-up and blocked)
  • Chrome 61/Windows 7 : the filepicker never appears

Where is the actual issue to fix : in my code, in VueJS or in Chrome?

Additionnal information and acknowledgement

A bug report was filed, using this project for reproduction purposes, in the VueJS GitHub project (#7028). I received a quick and thorough answer from LinuxBorg. Many thanks to him!

And many thanks to the VueJS project in general, while I have yet to heavily use that tool, I really like working with it so far. :)

About

A VueJS "file list" component that does not work correctly with every browser. Why?

Resources

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

No releases published

Packages

No packages published