DEVxDAO Code Review

This repository contains the records for the code reviews performed on behalf of the Code Review DAO (CRDAO) for the DEVxDAO.

Until a version of Proposal #185 is adopted by the DEVxDAO, the Code Review process adhered to will try to satisfy the requirements upvoted by the DEVxDAO Voting Associates outlines in Proposal #191. Similarly, the Definition of Done provided in Proposal #196 is used as a guideline but not a pass/fail requirement until approved by vote of the DEVxDAO Voting Associates.

These approved-by-vote requirements are:

--

The DxD resolves that the primary output of a code review should affirm the following objectives:

Documentation:

• Low level function documentation

(Unit) Testing

• Does the software do what is advertised in the milestone
• Critical path test coverage
  • At least one positive path test
  • At least one negative path test
  • Additional path tests are preferred (But not required)
• API endpoints require tests (if applicable)
• Coding standards
  • Reasonable compliance with then evolving coding standards under the layer 1 solution chosen in the given grants
• License compliance checks: E.G.: Plagiarism/Attribution, Copyright violation etc with regard to the MIT license.

Meanwhile, some of the proposed requirements in Proposal 185 will also be tested and reported on informationally only.

--

Projects Milestone Code Reviews will be represented in the filesystem of this repository as follows:

• Reviews
  • Project Number - Short Name
    • Milestone Number - Short Name

For example: /Reviews/100 - Fantastic Project/1 - Alpha Version