Handles all cases of See element

[AleksandrKetovAcumatica]

Problem: Current handler of See element only supports Href attribute, Langword and Cref attributes are not supported.

This PR adds a support of all See use cases with customizable URL creation.

[RicoSuter]

Ref for me to review:

PR #178 Review: "Handles all cases of See element"

PR: #178
Author: AleksandrKetovAcumatica
Review Date: 2025-12-16

---

Overview

Purpose: Adds support for all <see> XML documentation element use cases (langword, href, cref attributes) with customizable URL creation through new XmlDocsOptions callbacks.

Files Changed: 6 files, +241/-56 lines

File	Changes
XmlDocsExtensionsTests.cs	+42 (new test + helper class)
ContextualType.cs	+7/-7 (variable rename)
XmlDocsExtensions.cs	+117/-31 (main feature)
XmlDocsFormatting.cs	+52/-17 (formatting helpers)
XmlDocsKeys.cs	+5 (new constant)
XmlDocsOptions.cs	+18/-1 (new callbacks)

---

Critical Issue

Compilation Will Fail - Missing Method Dependencies

The ProcessParagraph method in XmlDocsExtensions.cs calls methods that are private in XmlDocsFormatting.cs:

// These are called from XmlDocsExtensions.cs but are private in XmlDocsFormatting.cs
stringBuilder.AppendHtmlParagraph(element, options);
stringBuilder.AppendMarkdownParagraph(element, options);
stringBuilder.AppendUnformattedElement(element);

The PR diff shows these being made public with new signatures, but the dictionary-based dispatch in XmlDocsFormatting.cs (lines 86-109) expects Func<StringBuilder, XElement, StringBuilder>, not the new signatures that include XmlDocsOptions.

Resolution: Update the dictionary signatures or create overloaded methods.

---

Architecture Review

Strengths

Aspect	Rating	Notes
Extensibility Model	A	Callback design is excellent and follows Strategy Pattern
Open/Closed Principle	A	New URL strategies can be added without modifying existing code
Interface Segregation	A	Optional callbacks - consumers only specify what they need

Concerns

Aspect	Rating	Notes
Separation of Concerns	B-	ProcessParagraph duplicates AppendFormattedElement() logic
Backwards Compatibility	B	Behavioral change for langword (now outputs as link)
Dependency Inversion	B	Hard-coded Microsoft Learn URL (though overridable)

Extensibility Model Analysis

The new XmlDocsOptions callbacks are well-designed:

public Func<string, string>? CrefToUrl { get; set; }
public Func<string, string>? LangwordToUrl { get; set; }
public Func<string, string>? HrefToUrl { get; set; }

Pros:

• Allows consumers to link cref values to their own documentation systems (DocFX, Sandcastle, custom APIs)
• Override langword to use different documentation sources
• Transform href URLs (URL rewriting, proxying, validation)
• Sensible defaults: langword → Microsoft Learn, href → passthrough, cref → requires explicit config

Alternative Considered: Could have used an interface (IUrlResolver) but Func<> delegates are simpler and more idiomatic for this use case.

---

Code Quality Issues

Missing XML Documentation

New public methods lack XML docs (project has GenerateDocumentationFile=true):

• ProcessSeeElement - no documentation
• AppendFormattedLink - no documentation
• AppendHtmlParagraph - signature changed, docs need update
• AppendMarkdownParagraph - signature changed, docs need update
• AppendUnformattedElement - made public, needs docs

Example fix:

/// <summary>
/// Appends a formatted hyperlink to the string builder using the specified formatting mode.
/// </summary>
/// <param name="stringBuilder">The current <see cref="StringBuilder"/>.</param>
/// <param name="linkText">The display text for the link.</param>
/// <param name="linkUrl">The URL target for the link.</param>
/// <param name="formattingMode">The formatting mode for generating link markup.</param>
/// <returns>The <paramref name="stringBuilder"/> for method chaining.</returns>
public static StringBuilder AppendFormattedLink(
    this StringBuilder stringBuilder,
    string linkText,
    string linkUrl,
    XmlDocsFormattingMode formattingMode)

Code Duplication

Cref trimming logic appears in two places:

Location 1: ProcessSeeElement (new code)

var trimmedCref = crefAttribute.Value.Trim(ToXmlDocsContentTrimChars).Trim();
trimmedCref = trimmedCref.FirstToken('(');
trimmedCref = trimmedCref.LastToken('.');

Location 2: ToXmlDocsContent (existing code, lines 369-374)

var trimmed = attribute.Value.Trim(ToXmlDocsContentTrimChars).Trim();
trimmed = trimmed.FirstToken('(');
trimmed = trimmed.LastToken('.');

Recommendation: Extract into shared helper:

private static string FormatCrefForDisplay(string crefValue)
{
    var trimmed = crefValue.Trim(ToXmlDocsContentTrimChars).Trim();
    return trimmed.FirstToken('(').LastToken('.');
}

---

.NET Best Practices Issues

String Allocation Optimization

// Current (runtime allocation)
private static readonly string LearnMicrosoftComLink = "https://learn.microsoft.com/...";

// Better (compile-time constant)
private const string LearnMicrosoftComLink = "https://learn.microsoft.com/...";

No Exception Handling for Callbacks

User-provided delegates could throw:

url = options.LangwordToUrl(langwordAttribute.Value); // Could throw!

Recommendation: Wrap delegate calls in try-catch:

if (options.LangwordToUrl != null)
{
    try
    {
        url = options.LangwordToUrl(langwordAttribute.Value);
    }
    catch
    {
        // Fall back to default behavior
        url = $"{LearnMicrosoftComLink}{langwordAttribute.Value}";
    }
}

No Null Parameter Validation

private static void ProcessSeeElement(XElement element, StringBuilder value, XmlDocsOptions options)
{
    // No null checks on element, value, or options
}

Recommendation: Add defensive checks following existing patterns:

if (element == null || value == null)
    return;

options ??= XmlDocsOptions.Default;

---

C# Best Practices Suggestions

Use Modern Null Patterns

The project uses LangVersion=latest and Nullable=enable.

Current:

if (langwordAttribute != null)
{
    if (options.LangwordToUrl != null)
    {
        url = options.LangwordToUrl(langwordAttribute.Value);
    }
    else
    {
        url = $"{LearnMicrosoftComLink}{langwordAttribute.Value}";
    }
}

Recommended:

if (langwordAttribute is not null)
{
    url = options.LangwordToUrl?.Invoke(langwordAttribute.Value)
          ?? $"{LearnMicrosoftComLink}{langwordAttribute.Value}";
}

Consider Switch Expressions

Current:

switch (formattingMode)
{
    case XmlDocsFormattingMode.Html:
        stringBuilder.Append("<a href=\"", linkUrl, "\">", linkText, "</a>");
        break;
    case XmlDocsFormattingMode.Markdown:
        stringBuilder.Append("[", linkText, "](", linkUrl, ")");
        break;
    case XmlDocsFormattingMode.None:
    default:
        stringBuilder.Append(linkText);
        break;
}
return stringBuilder;

Alternative:

return formattingMode switch
{
    XmlDocsFormattingMode.Html => stringBuilder.Append("<a href=\"", linkUrl, "\">", linkText, "</a>"),
    XmlDocsFormattingMode.Markdown => stringBuilder.Append("[", linkText, "](", linkUrl, ")"),
    _ => stringBuilder.Append(linkText)
};

Variable Rename is Good

The field → fieldInfo rename in ContextualType.cs follows codebase conventions and improves clarity.

---

Test Coverage

Strengths

• Tests both nested and top-level <see> tags
• Tests customization via all three callbacks
• Good expected output verification

Suggestions

• Add test for FormattingMode.None to verify no links are created
• Add test for null/empty callback behavior
• Add test for callback that throws exception (if exception handling is added)

---

Recommendations Summary

Must Fix (Blocking)

#	Issue	Priority
1	Fix method visibility/signature issues that will break compilation	Critical
2	Add XML documentation to all new public methods	High

Should Fix

#	Issue	Priority
3	Use const for LearnMicrosoftComLink	Medium
4	Add null checks and exception handling for callbacks	Medium
5	Use is not null pattern matching	Medium

Consider

#	Issue	Priority
6	Remove redundant ProcessParagraph method	Low
7	Document behavioral change for langword in release notes	Low

---

Final Verdict

Category	Score
Architecture	B+
Code Quality	C+
.NET Best Practices	B
C# Idioms	B
Test Coverage	B
Overall	B-

Summary

The conceptual design is solid - the callback-based extensibility model for URL generation is well-designed, follows .NET conventions, and adds genuine value for library consumers who need to link XML doc references to their own documentation systems.

However, the implementation needs work:

1. Critical compilation issue must be resolved
2. Code duplication should be eliminated
3. Missing documentation must be added
4. Modern C# patterns should be adopted

With the recommended fixes, this would be a valuable addition to the Namotion.Reflection library.

---

Review generated by Claude Code with multi-agent analysis

[AleksandrKetovAcumatica]

Hey, @RicoSuter. I've addressed some of comments mentioned above. Can you please review?