Skip to content

Imputation - Timesnet vs NonStationaryTransformer #775

@omkar-334

Description

@omkar-334

in the leaderboard, for time series imputation task, timesnet is reported as first and non-stationary transformer is reported as second.
However, when i run the scripts for ETTh1 without any changes, here are the results that i get -

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.125_TimesNet_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm16_nh8_el2_dl1_df32_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.0618780180811882, mae:0.16756796836853027

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.25_TimesNet_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm16_nh8_el2_dl1_df32_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.08032868057489395, mae:0.19080348312854767

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.375_TimesNet_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm16_nh8_el2_dl1_df32_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.09744171798229218, mae:0.2092771679162979

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.5_TimesNet_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm16_nh8_el2_dl1_df32_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.11592429876327515, mae:0.22686615586280823

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.125_Nonstationary_Transformer_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm128_nh8_el2_dl1_df128_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.04747990891337395, mae:0.14657214283943176

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.25_Nonstationary_Transformer_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm128_nh8_el2_dl1_df128_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.06437327712774277, mae:0.16930104792118073

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.375_Nonstationary_Transformer_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm128_nh8_el2_dl1_df128_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.08262055367231369, mae:0.1922348588705063

imputation_ETTh1_mask_0.5_Nonstationary_Transformer_ETTh1_ftM_sl96_ll0_pl0_dm128_nh8_el2_dl1_df128_expand2_dc4_fc3_ebtimeF_dtTrue_Exp_0  
mse:0.10656864196062088, mae:0.21720004081726074

This shows that non-stationary transformer beats timesnet in this task....
Any explanation for this?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions