Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Were you able to complete this ring? #1

Open
Cosmopal opened this issue Jul 6, 2024 · 7 comments
Open

Were you able to complete this ring? #1

Cosmopal opened this issue Jul 6, 2024 · 7 comments
Assignees
Labels
question Further information is requested

Comments

@Cosmopal
Copy link

Cosmopal commented Jul 6, 2024

Hey,
The project looks very promising, I would love to colab and get this to completion.

@rabits rabits added the question Further information is requested label Jul 6, 2024
@rabits rabits self-assigned this Jul 6, 2024
@rabits
Copy link
Member

rabits commented Jul 6, 2024

Hi @Cosmopal , no unfortunately I was not able to actually implement it. The complexity, as far I remember, was:

  • 2.4Ghz antenna design - quite a complicated topic.
  • Battery - had a talk to manufacturers and producing of such were pricey
  • Vibration device design was a fail since I'm not that great in mini-physics of magnetic fields and without such vibration the ring looks incomplete.

So if you wish to try to actually build it or can somehow help with the issues - that could be a great kick for me to continue the hw & firmware development. For now it's not really needed by anyone - so I stopped development since have some pressing projects.

As far I see I can copy the antenna design of the ring I used as prototype or try to get OmniRing design: https://www.cse.psu.edu/~mkg31/projects/omniring/ , but not quite sure if that will fit... The battery for sure can be used from another cheap smart ring, but about the vibration device I'm still not sure.

@Cosmopal
Copy link
Author

Cosmopal commented Jul 6, 2024

I think building the ring incrementally will be more practical. We can start small and at least have a working prototype on which we can build up. It's a challenging project for me too, which is why my idea of a first version was very small - basically a counting ring that keeps the count of number of times you touched its touch sensor, and is able to transmit that info. We can modify your current design to include a touch sensor instead of the vibration motor.

Can you share some details about the three challenges you mentioned above? Let me take a stab at it.
Meanwhile, we could:

  • Replace the BT sensor with NFC, which we can use for both comms and charging
  • Leave vibration out of scope if it doesn't work out.

The OmniRing's paper is there, but the design, specs or program is not available. One has to fill a Google form to request info. I did try to reach out to OmniRing team, but they have not been responding.

A ring is a very potent wearable device, and I'd love to have a tinkerable open source ring.

@rabits
Copy link
Member

rabits commented Jul 7, 2024

I think it's reasonable to build it incrementally - for sure you can remove some unnecessary parts (just do not fill the places there on the PCB). There is a physical button included in the design, because I found that touch button is not work that great - but if you need you can modify it to touch for sure.

"Replace the BT sensor with NFC" - what do you mean? Not quite sure I understand how nfc will work as a charger and what is "BT sensor".

And what kind of additional info I can provide? Not sure if you looked into the repo - there are 3d models, PCB and sample firmware (just the beginning of it), so it contains everything I have for now. And I recalled that I managed to replace the pcb antenna with solid state one, so one problem less!

@Cosmopal
Copy link
Author

Cosmopal commented Jul 7, 2024

Yes, I found the docs you had put in the repo. I’m still going through them. I was looking for details like:

  • which battery vendors you talked to and what price range did you find?
  • What exactly was the challenge with the vibration motor? Was the magnetism from it causing issues with circuit?

@rabits
Copy link
Member

rabits commented Jul 7, 2024

  • About batteries I talked to:
    • Shenzhen Ykxbattery Energy Co., Ltd., they've requested MOQ 20000pcs and sample making cost is $650.
    • Shenzhen Cowon Technology Limited and General Electronics Technology Co., Ltd., but their batteries was not "arc" type
  • Vibration device - even the smallest motors are actually don't fit into the form-factor, so I thought about making a custom magnetic-induction one, where magnet mass will be moved in a chamber between 2 points back and forth hitting the walls and making vibration this way: vibro_device-mk1.blend. I tested a couple of implementations, but they were working not well...
    • First iteration with the small magnet (1h2d) - incorrect magnetic field:
    • Second iteration was with ferromagnetic metal as mass - no pics, the mass moved around but did not made any impact and easily stuck.

@QuartzLibrary
Copy link

Hi there! Just found this while looking up OS ring designs.

A couple of thoughts in case they are helpful:

  • Things like batteries could be sourced by cannibalizing cheap rings from Aliexpress or similar electronics. That has its own challenges, but could allow you to get a prototype up and running.
  • Random thought on vibration is that if tactile feedback is what's desired, then maybe having the ring exert a light pressure on the finger is sufficient (and less energy intensive?). This can still allow for waterproofing if the 'piston' is moved from behind a wall of plastic. Still not as self-contained though.
  • While on the topic of whacky ideas, a very small Peltier module could also in theory provide physical feedback.
  • I like the idea of inobtrusive wearables, but ideally I would like them to be even more set-and-forget than rings. A design that looks more like blood-glucose monitors, might be easier to design and very cheap to produce. Think a small disk you stick to your arm, or ankle, or whatever really, and forget about for the next two weeks or more.
    I was looking for OS rings designs to see how hard it would be to repurpose them for this, as it seems much easier.

@nmn28
Copy link

nmn28 commented Sep 20, 2024

hi guys. this is the battery that oura ring uses: 3.7V 16mAh Lithium Battery - Grepow YE160723G. its custom curved lipo.

would love to connect further

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
question Further information is requested
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

4 participants