forked from lkujaw/motif
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
/
CLOSEDBUGS
561 lines (357 loc) · 22.4 KB
/
CLOSEDBUGS
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
------- Closed defects in project motif-code -------
Component: MWM Sub-component: MWM programmatic inter
CDExc04974 Performance improvement for loading Mwm unspecified pixmap
Component: MWM Sub-component: MWM user interface
CDExc09508 Geometry in icon box seems a little of
Component: UIL Sub-component: Mrm library
CDExc20147 In Mrm.h the value of RGMListSizeMax is set to 100
CDExc23994 potential minor memory leak with UIL render table
Component: UIL Sub-component: UIL
CDExc23721 Uil Library does not function properly in a 64-bit envorinment
CDExc23723 Colors in XmRenditions in UIL Cause Program to Abor
Component: Xm Sub-component:
CDExc11803 XsetCloseDown Not supported on X11-XNews serve
CDExc12623 XmClipboard man page incompatible with Solaris ma
CDExc16992 Can`t enter cc: in compose windo
CDExc17274 Assertions 3, 6, and 7 fail in ColorObj testcase
Component: Xm Sub-component: ANSI-C compliance
CDExc22903 Misc. compiler warning
CDExc23666 VSM: problem with XmProcessTraversa
Component: Xm Sub-component: BaseClass
CDExc23205 BaseClass.c`_XmTransformSubResources refers to R5 Xt bugs, probably fixe
Component: Xm Sub-component: Build issues
CDExc23985 make: Fatal error: Don`t know how to make target `os2Lib.rules
CDExc23987 possible difficulty building 2.1.20 with gcc
CDExc24111 Missing entries from the Xm and Mrm export list
Component: Xm Sub-component: C++ .h compile
CDExc09648 C++ linake proble
Component: Xm Sub-component: Clipboard
CDExc23920 XmClipboardUndoCopy crashes VSM4.1 funcs/clpundocp tes
CDExc24009 users of ClipboardFindItem must check validity of heade
Component: Xm Sub-component: Color
CDExc24003 closing 2nd display causes 1st to cras
Component: Xm Sub-component: Demos
CDExc23986 failures to install in hellomotifi18n dem
Component: Xm Sub-component: Drag and Drop
CDExc09420 setting f.menu <Btn2Down> interferes with DN
CDExc23482 XmDisplay does not support multiscreen applicatio
CDExc24060 VSM: Funcs/XmDropSiteRegister fails on Alph
CDExc24066 Dialog fails to post if drag is in progress; pointer grab locks system
CDExc24067 Attempting to drag from a pulldown menu locks display
Component: Xm Sub-component: Geometry Management Me
CDExc20432 slight layout differences in Pane if children set values before managed/re
Component: Xm Sub-component: Memory issues
CDExc23475 Motif binary compatibility mechanism has bug in XmResolve[All]PartOffse
CDExc23674 XmResolveAllPartOffsets appears to be off by one class leve
CDExc23709 Memory leaks in various widget
CDExc23725 Memory Leak in _XmRenditionCop
Component: Xm Sub-component: Menu button interactio
CDExc09773 Menus must ungrab with CurrentTime
CDExc20402 Cascade button keeps highlight when pull down is gon
CDExc20403 incorrectly highlight 2 buttons in tear-off men
Component: Xm Sub-component: Menu event handling
CDExc09772 Changes make to menus and mwm to support event time - was CurrentTime -
CDExc20060 Motif menu accellarators are confused by don`t care modifier bit
CDExc20401 grab conflict proble
CDExc24004 Check for NULL pointer uses the wrong field
Component: Xm Sub-component: Menu layout
CDExc20404 cascade button not supported in Tear-off men
Component: Xm Sub-component: PC Style Convergence
CDExc22767 moving left off of leftmost menu button should select window men
Component: Xm Sub-component: Pixmap Converters
CDExc23099 Missing pixmap
Component: Xm Sub-component: Pixmap cache
CDExc19778 XmGePixmapByDepth core dumps on monochrome system
Component: Xm Sub-component: Synthetic Resources
CDExc23943 Manager GetValuesHook has obsolete code for NULL ArgVa
Component: Xm Sub-component: TearOff Menus
CDExc23923 Tear off menu crash when hitting escap
Component: Xm Sub-component: Traits Other
CDExc23944 XmQTcareParentVisual redraw methods need to check that widget is realized
Component: Xm Sub-component: Translations and Virtu
CDExc23279 Sun virtual bindings out of dat
Component: Xm Sub-component: VendorShell
CDExc23560 Thread unsafe of XmeGetDefaultRenderTabl
CDExc23672 Events can sometime `sneak` in during processing of primary modal
CDExc23720 XtRemoveGrab asked to remove a widget not on the lis
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmArrowButtonGadget
CDExc20513 Motif sash sizing error
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmCascadeButton
CDExc09768 problem with two cascade buttons are sharing the same submenu pan
CDExc24069 Program dies in call to XmCascadeButtonHighligh
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmComboBox
CDExc22532 Combo Box arrow still active when XmNarrowSize set to
CDExc23729 XmComboBox Cuts Off Text in Text Fiel
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmCommand
CDExc23892 CDExc23345 needs to be reversed or fixed differentl
CDExc23990 XmCommandAppendValue causes TCM Error in VSM4.1 on Alph
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmContainer
CDExc23204 XmContainer marquee selection funky in out-of-bounds case
CDExc23305 XmContainer denies geometry requests for children resizin
CDExc24005 container widget outline loses widget
CDExc24006 Container has drag & drop problems, causes SEG
CDExc24061 Container widget always supports inappropriate drag operations
CDExc24062 Container widget does not react properly to Button1Down event
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmDialogShell
CDExc23706 dialog box doesn`t take input after rapid clicking away from button
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmDisplay
CDExc23773 Invalid use of XtGetValue function on create only resource
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmDrawnButton
CDExc23999 DrawnButton in menu produces warning, and has no translation
CDExc24000 DrawnButton does not show proper visuals when in men
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmFileSelectionBox
CDExc23897 compound widget display difference
CDExc23921 VSM4.1 widgets/filesb1{2} causes SIGBUS on HP-U
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmIconGadget
CDExc19866 XmIconGadget doesn`t honor XmNlayoutDirection resourc
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmIm
CDExc23895 A bug in XmText and XmList widget
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmLabel
CDExc23608 Indicator size not recalculated in ToggleBtn when String is used as labe
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmList
CDExc19518 ListBeginExtend behaves non-intuitively when no selection exist
CDExc19559 List c-a-Btn1 actions are wrong
CDExc19642 Toolkit/List/List2 test List1SW widget scrollbar too lon
CDExc22405 Item highlightlighting may erase parts of adjacent item
CDExc23894 fatal defect in XmList widge
CDExc23896 XmList fails to adjust to size changes, clips dat
CDExc23914 auto-created IC not free
CDExc23996 Highlight spacing off by one for XmLis
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmMenuShell
CDExc23280 XmMenuShell issues unnecessary XmFontListFree cal
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmNotebook
CDExc20033 XmNotebook: can`t set XmNcurrentPageNumber before widget is realize
CDExc23791 Tabs do not go to correct `heights` for prior page numbers in noteboo
CDExc23797 notebook first back page drawn incorrectly for some XmNbindingType
CDExc23798 notebook size incorrect with specific XmNbackPagePlacement/XmNorientatio
CDExc23801 notebook size includes tab scrollers even if not manage
CDExc23802 top major tab shadow not drawn if frameShadowThickness =
CDExc24070 Notebook gives error when the bindingType is XmSPIRAL
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmPanedWindow/Sash
CDExc23984 XmPanedWindow does not respond to change in XmNorientatio
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmPushButtonGadget
CDExc17352 Btn2 double-click while Btn1 holds down a button gadget, stay
CDExc24011 PushBG has dup call to XtSetKeyboardFocus in Enter event handler
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmRenderTable/XmFontLi
CDExc23590 XmeGetDefaultTable`s doc need new inf
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmRowColumn WorkArea|R
CDExc23893 lib/Xm/RowColumn.h missing function prototype
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmScrolledWindow
CDExc04585 paging grab need to apply to inner SW, plus the begin/end line data should
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmSelectionBox
CDExc21358 The default action in the SelectionBox ListItems XmList widget is broken
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmSpinBox
CDExc23604 XmSpinBox does not handle XmManager resources properl
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmString
CDExc23922 funcs/stlength VSM4.1 test causes warning on Solari
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmText
CDExc05686 It is impossible to set the slider color on a scrollbar of a scrolled Text
CDExc16629 XmTextPosToXY can mess up curso
CDExc23645 XmTextSetTopCharacter does not work for zero positio
CDExc23898 locale bug in XmTextSetTopCharacter in Motif2.
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmTextField
CDExc20409 Performance bug in XmTextFiel
CDExc20656 The XmTextField returns the type `TEXT` as the selection type
CDExc24076 Compilation warnings in TextField widget code
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmToggleButton
CDExc08708 ToggleButton`s XmNvalueChangedCallback firing incorrectl
CDExc20667 Toggles` XmNselectPixmap handling doesn`t detect NULL pixma
CDExc23615 ToggleBtn indicator resizes automatically even if XmNindicatorSize is se
CDExc24058 VSM: Widgets/XmToggleButton/3 fails on Alph
CDExc24064 ToggleBtn indicatorSize is zero if no pixmap is specifie
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmToggleButtonGadget
CDExc23991 XmToggleButtonGadgetGetState causes TCM Error in VSM4.
CDExc24059 VSM: Widgets/XmToggleButtonGadget/3 fails on Alph
CDExc24065 ToggleBtnGadget indicatorSize is zero if no pixmap is specified
CDExc24074 DisArm call back is not redrawing the visual correctly.
CDExc24075 ToggleButtonGadget`s XmNvalueChangedCallback gives some problem
Component: Xm Sub-component: other
CDExc20062 XmosP.h may need to change alloca definition for Solaris 2.
CDExc20066 _XmVirtKeysLoadFileBindings puts comments from .motifbind file into the MO
CDExc23236 Xmos.c handling of select uses wrong types on some system
CDExc23237 Messages.c has nested comment
CDExc23643 Supplied CTL code for Xm/XmXOC.h has Xlcint.h as include which is X11`
CDExc23689 Name space collision between /usr/include/term.h and Xm.
CDExc23722 Bug in Motif 2.1 Mrm Library with TabList
CDExc23891 testing applications for binary compatibility with earlier release
CDExc24019 osfHelp on sun doesn`t bind to <Key>F
Component: other Sub-component: Build issues
CDExc09774 SharedXmRev is still defined as 1.
CDExc22904 Misc. compiler warning
CDExc23416 Add Motif macros: BuildMotifDemos BuildMotifConfig BuildWMLTabl
CDExc23992 exportlistgen needs to eliminate warnings about symbols missing from expor
Component: other Sub-component: Exm C Reference Widget
CDExc09667 ExmMenuButton in pulldown menu does not respond if menu is posted by a cli
Component: other Sub-component: WML
CDExc05118 Warnings and prototypes in wml
Component: other Sub-component: other
CDExc06053 VenShellM1 Panel 5 test logic erroneous
CDExc21080 XmCxxXmString.h copy constructor arg should be cons
CDExc23850 2.1.n release notes needs information about UID file
------- Closed defects in project motif-test -------
Component: MT Sub-component:
CDExc23534 Tests/DragAndDrop/DNDDrop2 has bulltenboard animation style out wron
CDExc23535 Auto scrolling in DNDScrool of tests/DragAndDrop is not workin
Component: MWM Sub-component: MWM programmatic inter
CDExc06738 Update RUN in ./tests/mwm/P
CDExc08730 PIVMwm.dat tells you to click on the wrong butto
CDExc09351 some tests fail in VenShellM
Component: MWM Sub-component: MWM user interface
CDExc07988 TransFamilyM1 test needs some looking into
CDExc08732 test mwmwrc file syntax wron
CDExc23491 Inconsistancy in docs/tests for mw
Component: UIL Sub-component: UIL
CDExc07945 Compiler warnings while building uil/Manual/callUil test
CDExc07959 uil/Manual/validator/RUN script has wrong location of ui
CDExc08012 uil/dataStructs/Translations should be updated to reflect expected behavio
Component: Xm Sub-component: Clipboard
CDExc09391 CopyByName seems to fail in test Cutpaste4
Component: Xm Sub-component: Cxx Foundry Widgets
CDExc08969 CxxManager test does not build
CDExc09527 In CxxManager and CxxPrimitive Coverage reports are wrong
Component: Xm Sub-component: Demos
CDExc09760 Compilation errors when building gmalloc.o in tests/internal/Performance/U
Component: Xm Sub-component: Drag and Drop
CDExc06759 Correct DNDDrop1 tes
CDExc07911 Instructions for DNDList1 should indicate you need a multi-line Text widge
CDExc08900 Instruction Panel should be changed for DNDDrop
CDExc08901 DNDScroll instructions has vertical and horizontal scrollbars switche
CDExc09631 Intruction Panel wrong for DNDScroll tes
Component: Xm Sub-component: I18N misc
CDExc09712 Missing new lines at end of .dat file
Component: Xm Sub-component: Menu button interactio
CDExc05914 SimpleM1 - test says there should be four pushbuttons displayed, but there
CDExc08226 Menu1 test does not compile cleanly on alpha
Component: Xm Sub-component: Menu event handling
CDExc07441 MenuBar1 does a KCancel when it really wants to do a ClickM
Component: Xm Sub-component: Performance
CDExc23536 tests/Performance has CSText in it
Component: Xm Sub-component: Resolution Independenc
CDExc06071 RIPanedWin3.Scr has a typ
Component: Xm Sub-component: TearOff Menus
CDExc07360 Test tries to add popup callback to row column widge
Component: Xm Sub-component: Uniform Transfer Model
CDExc24137 UTM tests fail to build due to use of CSTex
Component: Xm Sub-component: VendorShell
CDExc06761 Don`t know how to make target VenShellM2.da
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmComboBox
CDExc08654 ComboBox is a Manager not a Primitive and should be treated as such in Vis
CDExc09289 ComboBox4 not updating with items being added to list
CDExc23507 ComboBox1d test does not wor
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmDialogShell
CDExc06772 No .dat file for DiaShellM
CDExc06797 Test dies when destroying parent of a destroyed dialog message
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmDrawingArea
CDExc09654 Problem with DrawArea2 test
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmFileSelectionBox
CDExc24057 Widgets are getting resized when sensitivity changes
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmForm
CDExc08393 Form1h script file has a syntax erro
CDExc08640 Test crashing on Alpha due to script proble
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmLabel
CDExc07864 MessageDia4 test needs to change calls from XtVaSetValues to XtSetValues f
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmList
CDExc05904 ListM1 does not print message to term window as instructions suggest
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmPanedWindow/Sash
CDExc07266 Incorrect dimensions for paned window and its children
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmRowColumn WorkArea|R
CDExc07701 RowCol1 logs two visual differences when run on alph
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmScrollBar
CDExc24156 Scrollbar7 gives warning message and VISERRO
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmSpinBox
CDExc22661 SpinBox QATS tests are using wrong value for arrowOrientation
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmString
CDExc23502 Missing golden data for tests/XmString/StringTa
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmText
CDExc09472 Get error about not being able to load font in ScrollText3
Component: Xm Sub-component: XmTrackingLocate/Event
CDExc06132 Test Grab1 crashes on Sun and HP and OSF/1
CDExc07979 TrackingLocM2 test needs to be revisite
CDExc08938 Problems with instruction panel for TrackingLocM1
CDExc08953 Empty Shell widget in TrackingLocM
Component: Xm Sub-component: Xme Transfer API
CDExc06819 XmeClipboardSink segv`
CDExc08903 XmeTransfer test fails on alphas
Component: Xm Sub-component: other
CDExc20064 tests/Toolkit/Converters/Conversion2.c does not pass lin
CDExc20077 tests/Manual/validator has outdated reference lo
CDExc20082 Cutpaste4a give strange behavio
CDExc20085 stupid varargs code in test routine kills u
CDExc20089 XmeString test issues warnin
CDExc20090 XmeTransfer test screwed u
CDExc20095 ./XmeString: ERROR: incorrect XmString component encountere
CDExc20098 test claims that CR 5989 is still a proble
CDExc20101 VenShellM1 tests fai
CDExc20113 automated Toolkit/ComboBox tests fai
CDExc23215 tests/Toolkit/Extensibility/XmeTransfer doesn`t work at al
CDExc23217 HorPanedWin1 wrong about siz
CDExc23295 PanedWinM1 uses old XtGetValues(NULL
CDExc23296 MessageBM1 item does not appea
CDExc23306 ScrollText1 lies about resource setting
CDExc23311 Visual1 uses wrong handling for sensitivit
CDExc23328 Toolkit/Manual/BBoardM1 uses old form of XtGetValues(NULL
CDExc23508 Automate constraint widget testin
CDExc23928 Several tests in Toolkit/ResInd fail due to NULL ArgVa
CDExc23929 Several tests in Toolkit/Scrollbar fail due to NULL ArgVa
CDExc23983 Primitive/Label4 fails on Su
Component: other Sub-component: Automation
CDExc04952 mvsGetSubObjects must free memory allocated by XmFontListGetNextFont
CDExc05254 TransFamily test exits with a signal under automatio
CDExc06084 Automation is not doing the select for Text
CDExc06591 Uninitialized memory read in Create/mvsGetRscVal`mvsGetResourceValue- -
CDExc07311 Automation doesn`t do printfs of callbacks - could this be related to the
CDExc08232 segv, event/actions when using ClickKey <Mod1> Kq
CDExc09002 Automation dumps core in DragSliderValue if slider can not be found
CDExc23848 Automation Imakefile does not pass CDEBUGFLAG
CDExc23930 Several tests in Toolkit/Select depend on OSF site-specific directorie
CDExc23946 AutoWmCmd.c is corrupted
CDExc23956 Typo in QATS Automation error message
CDExc23982 RUN_auto script contains OSF-specific display nam
CDExc23993 Automation message SCRMSG19 is missing a wor
CDExc24010 QATS environment setup files contain OSF-specific informatio
CDExc24022 .motifbind file for HP-UX had bad osfMenu and osfMenuBar definition
CDExc24032 Select/Command2 golden .prt file needs to be re-recorde
CDExc24033 Error in script file for Container2
CDExc24037 Golden data for textSl needs to be re-recorde
Component: other Sub-component: UIL
CDExc04903 uil matrix tests are not complete
Component: other Sub-component: VendorShell
CDExc07291 Test instructions site the incorrect font for the pushbutton label
CDExc08736 DiaShell1 not compiling clean on Alph
Component: other Sub-component: XmDialogShell
CDExc04891 uil test ErrorDia hasdefunct resource
Component: other Sub-component: XmManager
CDExc08642 Manager directory not compiling clean on Alph
Component: other Sub-component: XmMenuShell
CDExc07244 The following tests in tests/Toolkit/Manual generate compiler warnings whe
Component: other Sub-component: XmPanedWindow/Sash
CDExc08645 Instruction wrong in HorPanedWin
Component: other Sub-component: XmPushButton
CDExc08601 Buttons directory not compiling clean on Alph
Component: other Sub-component: XmTrackingLocate/Event
CDExc07986 Instructions need a correction in TrackingLocM2 test
Component: other Sub-component: other
CDExc03831 Several tests in Constraint directory need looking into. Instructions don`
CDExc05398 Some Text tests use functions that are in Obsolete.
CDExc05441 ScrollText1, Instruction Panel 3, instruction number 2 - looks like incorr
CDExc05600 AutoParser leaks memor
CDExc06123 Defunct tests/uil/matrix directory, tests no longer usefu
CDExc06128 Makefile in Toolkit/Manual does not build all the test
CDExc06129 Instructions for ListM1 is wrong, no message sent to stdou
CDExc06131 Toolkit/Manual/SharedTearM1 segv when displayed onto a Sun or HP but not 3
CDExc06142 Toolkit/Manual/SharedTearM1 segv on the Sun - betelgeuse
CDExc07288 The following tests failed in VenShellM1
CDExc07449 RowCol* tests need to be added to the foreach loop in RUN.custom
CDExc07772 Top list CRs needing testcases can be inadvertently removed from the topli
CDExc08412 compilation warnings for UTM/UTMPrim1.
CDExc08935 DNDIcon1, Panel 7 wrong instructionin no. 3
CDExc09713 DND test does not run correctly
CDExc23543 Test failure of tests/Toolkit/Converters/RepType
CDExc23924 Crash in Toolkit/PanedWin/PanedWin
CDExc23927 Toolkit/Primitive/Label2 segv on Solari
CDExc23948 Primitive/Label5 uses obsolete _XmGetImageFromFile(
CDExc23965 Golden .prt file for Converters/RepType2 needs update for Motif 2.0 value
CDExc24035 .motifbind file for Sun needs updat
CDExc24038 MessageDiaM1 code does not match instruction pane
CDExc24055 ColorM1.h does not compile on Su
CDExc24174 Toolkit/CxxManager and Toolkit/CxxPrimitive directories are obsolet