diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index bdd010e..56dfd55 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -2,4 +2,6 @@ ![Medieval academics counting beans as imagined by Adobe Firefly](assets/beancounters3.jpg) +Project Status: WIP – Initial development is in progress, but there has not yet been a stable, usable release suitable for the public. + CER · BEANS is a framework for developing quantitative metrics for community engaged research (CER) that is balanced, nuanced, and expressive. It is a work in progress, and your feedback and contributions are welcomed. diff --git a/docs/index.html b/docs/index.html index d55538a..50d3286 100644 --- a/docs/index.html +++ b/docs/index.html @@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ -CER-BEANS: Community Engaged Research Balanced Evaluation and Assessments with Nuanced Scores - CER · BEANS: Community Engaged Research Balanced Expressions and Assessments with Nuanced Scores +CER-BEANS: Community Engaged Research Balanced Evaluation and Assessments with Nuanced Scores - CER ⋅ BEANS: Community Engaged Research Balanced Expressions and Assessments with Nuanced Scores @@ -802,9 +802,10 @@

Number of Participa

This is a total of 50 direct participants.

-
tg_number_of_participants <- 70
+
tg_number_of_participants <- 65
 fafi_number_of_participants <- 50
-stst_number_of_participants <- 7
+stst_number_of_participants <- 7 +bspd_number_of_participants <- 45
@@ -818,7 +819,9 @@

Marginalize tg_marginalized_proportions_value <- 0.95 tg_marginalized_proportions_coefficient <- 0.85 fafi_marginalized_proportions_value <- 0.75 -fafi_marginalized_proportions_coefficient <- 1 +fafi_marginalized_proportions_coefficient <- 1 +bspd_marginalized_proportions_value <- 0.95 +bspd_marginalized_proportions_coefficient <- 0.85

@@ -832,7 +835,9 @@

tg_intersectionally_marginalized_value <- 0.95 tg_intersectionally_marginalized_coefficient <- 0.85 fafi_intersectionally_marginalized_value <- 0.75 -fafi_intersectionally_marginalized_coefficient <- 1 +fafi_intersectionally_marginalized_coefficient <- 1 +bspd_intersectionally_marginalized_value <- 0.95 +bspd_intersectionally_marginalized_coefficient <- 0.85

@@ -844,7 +849,7 @@

Calc
-

We find that the Professional Development Project has a Participant Index (\(p_i\)) of 0.81 (adjusted) and a full Participant Score (\(p_s\)) of 127. Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure has a Participant Index (\(p_i\)) of 0.75 and a Participant Score (\(p_s\)) of 88.

+

We find that the Professional Development Project has a Participant Index (\(p_i\)) of 0.81 (adjusted) and a full Participant Score (\(p_s\)) of 118. Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure has a Participant Index (\(p_i\)) of 0.75 and a Participant Score (\(p_s\)) of 88.

@@ -856,23 +861,23 @@

Engagement

-
- @@ -1348,7 +1353,8 @@

Engagement Hours

stst_engagement_hours <- 16
 tg_engagement_hours <- 18
-fafi_engagement_hours <- 20
+fafi_engagement_hours <- 20 +bspd_engagement_hours <- 18
@@ -1356,7 +1362,8 @@

Frequency

stst_frequency_score <- 0.85
 tg_frequency_score <- 0.50
-fafi_frequency_score <- 0.75
+fafi_frequency_score <- 0.75 +bspd_frequency_score <- 0.50
@@ -1364,7 +1371,8 @@

Duration

stst_duration_score <- 0.75
 tg_duration_score <- 0.85
-fafi_duration_score <- 0.75
+fafi_duration_score <- 0.75 +bspd_duration_score <- 0.85
@@ -1385,23 +1393,23 @@

Infrastructure Score<
-
- @@ -1861,16 +1869,18 @@

Infrastructure Score<

Number of Intrastructure/Intermediate Products

stst_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 8
-tg_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 10
-fafi_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 12
+tg_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 20 +bspd_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 20 +fafi_number_of_infrastructure_products <- 12

Infrastructure Purpose

stst_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.90
-tg_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.90
-fafi_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.95
+tg_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.95 +bspd_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.95 +fafi_infrastructure_purpose <- 0.95
@@ -1878,7 +1888,8 @@

Infrastruct
stst_infrastructure_co_construction <- 0.10
 tg_infrastructure_co_construction <- 0.10
-fafi_infrastructure_co_construction <- 0.50
+bspd_infrastructure_co_construction <- 0.10 +fafi_infrastructure_co_construction <- 0.50

@@ -1899,23 +1910,23 @@

Outputs Score

-
- @@ -2376,7 +2387,8 @@

Number of Outpu
stst_number_of_outputs <- 1
 tg_number_of_outputs <- 0
-fafi_number_of_outputs <- 6
+bspd_number_of_outputs <- 0 +fafi_number_of_outputs <- 6

@@ -2384,7 +2396,8 @@

Distribution of Ven
stst_distribution_of_venues <- 0.10
 tg_distribution_of_venues <- 0.10
-fafi_distribution_of_venues <- 0.90
+bspd_distribution_of_venues <- 0.10 +fafi_distribution_of_venues <- 0.90

@@ -2392,7 +2405,8 @@

Inc
stst_inclusion_of_participants <- 0.90
 tg_inclusion_of_participants <- 0.10
-fafi_inclusion_of_participants <- 0.50
+bspd_inclusion_of_participants <- 0.10 +fafi_inclusion_of_participants <- 0.50

@@ -2413,23 +2427,23 @@

Sustainability

-
- @@ -2890,7 +2904,8 @@

Number of
stst_number_of_partners <- 2
 tg_number_of_partners <- 1
-fafi_number_of_partners <- 4
+bspd_number_of_partners <- 1 +fafi_number_of_partners <- 4

@@ -2898,7 +2913,8 @@

Distributio
stst_distribution_of_responsibility <- 0.5
 tg_distribution_of_responsibility <- 0.5
-fafi_distribution_of_responsibility <- 0.9
+bspd_distribution_of_responsibility <- 0.5 +fafi_distribution_of_responsibility <- 0.9

@@ -2906,7 +2922,8 @@

Distribut
stst_distribution_of_material_support <- 0.5
 tg_distribution_of_material_support <- 0.5
-fafi_distribution_of_material_support <- 0.5
+bspd_distribution_of_material_support <- 0.5 +fafi_distribution_of_material_support <- 0.5

@@ -2932,8 +2949,8 @@

Ripple Effects

Teacher Professional Development

For the Professional Development project, impact at each degree is determined this way:

@@ -2944,9 +2961,20 @@

Teacher P "Students", "Family Members" ), - values = c(70, 522, 2088) + values = c(65, 575, 2300) )

+
+
bspd_ripple <- data.frame(
+  group = c(0, 1, 2),
+  group_name = c(
+    "Teachers",
+    "Students",
+    "Family Members"
+  ),
+  values = c(45, 388, 1552)
+)
+

Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure

@@ -2958,30 +2986,30 @@

Fam
  • 3 Degrees of Separation: Because this is a project that links and empowers families and educators to best support the learning of K-12 students, the last degree of separation involves the potential families of the future K-12 students. Four family members for 648 students potentially results in 2592 family members per year.
  • -
    fafi_ripple <- data.frame(
    -  group = c(0, 1, 2, 3),
    -  group_name = c(
    -    "Participants",
    -    "Contemporaries",
    -    "Future Students",
    -    "Future Families"
    -  ),
    -  values = c(50, 524, 648, 2592)
    -)
    +
    fafi_ripple <- data.frame(
    +  group = c(0, 1, 2, 3),
    +  group_name = c(
    +    "Participants",
    +    "Contemporaries",
    +    "Future Students",
    +    "Future Families"
    +  ),
    +  values = c(50, 524, 648, 2592)
    +)

    STEM Studio

    -
    stst_ripple <- data.frame(
    -  group = c(0, 1, 2),
    -  group_name = c(
    -    "Participants",
    -    "Family Members",
    -    "Friends"
    -  ),
    -  values = c(7, 28, 35)
    -)
    +
    stst_ripple <- data.frame(
    +  group = c(0, 1, 2),
    +  group_name = c(
    +    "Participants",
    +    "Family Members",
    +    "Friends"
    +  ),
    +  values = c(7, 28, 35)
    +)
    @@ -2989,24 +3017,29 @@

    Cal
    -

    The Professional Development project has a Ripple Effect Score of 1529. The ripple effect plot, based on a Vogel Spiral, looks like this:

    +

    The Professional Development project has a Ripple Effect Score of 1672. The ripple effect plot, based on a Vogel Spiral, looks like this:

    -

    The Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure project has a Ripple Effect Score of 1818. The ripple effect plot looks like this:

    -

    The STEM Studio project has a Ripple Effect Score of 47. The ripple effect plot looks like this:

    +

    The Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure project has a Ripple Effect Score of 1818. The ripple effect plot looks like this:

    +

    The STEM Studio project has a Ripple Effect Score of 47. The ripple effect plot looks like this:

    +
    +
    +

    +
    +
    @@ -3030,7 +3063,7 @@

    Composite Impact Sc
    -

    The Overall Score \(S_O\) for the STEM Studio is 69, the Overall Score \(S_O\) for the Professional Development is 182, and the Overall Score \(S_O\) for Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure is 183.

    +

    The Overall Score \(S_O\) for the STEM Studio is 69, the Overall Score \(S_O\) for the Professional Development is 197, and the Overall Score \(S_O\) for Family as Faculty as an Infrastructure is 183.

    Overall Representation

    @@ -3051,19 +3084,22 @@

    Overall Representat

    Professional Development Example

    An example of a detailed badge for a professional development program at a school. This badge contains multiple levels of information including the overall score, the ripple effect score, and direct indicators.

    -

    +

    +
    +
    +

    Family as Faculty as Infrastructure Example

    -

    +

    STEM Studio Example

    -

    +

    @@ -3072,16 +3108,15 @@

    STEM Studio Example

    Reuse

    Citation

    BibTeX citation:
    @misc{fprice2023,
       author = {Jeremy F Price},
    -  title = {CER \&Middot; {BEANS:} {Community} {Engaged} {Research}
    -    {Balanced} {Expressions} and {Assessments} with {Nuanced} {Scores}},
    +  title = {CER ⋅ {BEANS:} {Community} {Engaged} {Research} {Balanced}
    +    {Expressions} and {Assessments} with {Nuanced} {Scores}},
       date = {2023},
       url = {https://github.com/jeremyfprice/cer-beans},
       langid = {en}
     }
     
    For attribution, please cite this work as:
    -Jeremy F Price. 2023. “CER &Middot; BEANS: Community Engaged -Research Balanced Expressions and Assessments with Nuanced -Scores.” https://github.com/jeremyfprice/cer-beans. +Jeremy F Price. 2023. “CER ⋅ BEANS: Community Engaged Research +Balanced Expressions and Assessments with Nuanced Scores.” https://github.com/jeremyfprice/cer-beans.