You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
As website user
I want to see links to both peer reviewed and pre-publication manuscript
So that I am fullly aware of the peer review status of the linked manuscript
Acceptance criteria
Given I am on a dataset page
When I navigate to the associated manuscripts section
Then if appropriate I see a link to a pre-print archive such as bioXriv for the associated pre-publication manuscript
and this link is clearly labelled as a preprint link.
Given I am on a dataset page
And the dataset has links to a manuscript that is peer reviewed
Then I see a link to the peer reviewed manuscript
Additional Info
The issue that requires addressing:
Linking a dataset to a peer reviewed manuscript is fine, but bioXriv manuscripts are not peer reviewed so we should not add those links via the same dataset_manuscript table. or if we do we have to have a flag to show "not peer reviewed" and change the wording of the display for those.
Scenario 1:
Manuscript is submitted to BioXriv and the dataset is released in GigaDB before the manuscript has been reviewed, or even submitted (example case was dataset 100622, where BGI wanted to publish and release the genome fast, within 20days from sample collection).
Scenario 2:
Even though the manuscript has been reviewed and accepted we may wish to include the link to the bioXriv version as well as the final manuscript.
Expected action:
either - addition of an external link type "Pre-Print" to enable the inclusion of the manuscript preprint link with an appropriate text box in the dataset page
or - the addition of another column in the dataset_manuscript table to flag manuscript link as not-peer-reviewed, and changes to the website to display those links with different wording.
User story
Acceptance criteria
Additional Info
The issue that requires addressing:
Linking a dataset to a peer reviewed manuscript is fine, but bioXriv manuscripts are not peer reviewed so we should not add those links via the same dataset_manuscript table. or if we do we have to have a flag to show "not peer reviewed" and change the wording of the display for those.
Scenario 1:
Manuscript is submitted to BioXriv and the dataset is released in GigaDB before the manuscript has been reviewed, or even submitted (example case was dataset 100622, where BGI wanted to publish and release the genome fast, within 20days from sample collection).
Scenario 2:
Even though the manuscript has been reviewed and accepted we may wish to include the link to the bioXriv version as well as the final manuscript.
Expected action:
either - addition of an external link type "Pre-Print" to enable the inclusion of the manuscript preprint link with an appropriate text box in the dataset page
or - the addition of another column in the dataset_manuscript table to flag manuscript link as not-peer-reviewed, and changes to the website to display those links with different wording.
Dependent on this ticket to be completed first:
Product Backlog Item Ready Checklist
Product Backlog Item Done Checklist
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: