SMTP configuration

[mihha]

Guys, I am trying to configure docker installation to send emails, but something is not working, and I can't see any messages in any log to see what exactly is wrong

I have this in my docker file

  web:
    image: riggraz/astuto:latest
    environment:
      POSTGRES_USER: postgres
      POSTGRES_PASSWORD: MY_PASSWORD
      BASE_URL: https://my_url.com
      SECRET_KEY_BASE: MY_SECRET_KEY
      EMAIL_DELIVERY_METHOD: smtp
      EMAIL_SMTP_HOST: "my_amazon_smtp_host_address"
      EMAIL_SMTP_PORT: 465
      EMAIL_SMTP_USER: "my_ses_username"
      EMAIL_SMTP_PASS: "my_ses_username_password"
      EMAIL_SMTP_AUTH: true
      EMAIL_SMTP_TLS: true
      EMAIL_MAIL_FROM: "[email protected]"
      EMAIL_MAIL_REPLY_TO: "[email protected]"

SMTP server credentials, port and everything else is for sure correct, because I have checked this with my other self-hosted service

I have no idea how to debug this

Can someone point me into the right direction, please?

[inthebrilliantblue]

Im pretty sure astuto is just broken when it comes to email. As far as I can tell, it has no proper logging for when someone provides incorrect SMTP user / pass to it, as it still gives me logs that it sent a confirmation email successfully even though I intentionally gave it wrong credentials to try to force the logs to change. And based on this tickets age with no replies, it doesnt give me the warm fuzzies about a fix.

[mihha]

I agree to your comment about the fix. Already gave up on Astuto two weeks ago

Too bad, because this looked promising, but I had to move on and use something else

[pilasguru]

Astuto has mail option broken.

I have configured a local (docker) smtp proxy without validation requirements and this is the log each time astuto try to send an e-mail:

2024-05-31T19:31:35.886096+00:00 a64adacb47b7 postfix/smtpd[139]: connect from astuto-web-1.astuto_astuto[172.27.0.4]
2024-05-31T19:31:35.888266+00:00 a64adacb47b7 postfix/smtpd[139]: lost connection after AUTH from astuto-web-1.astuto_astuto[172.27.0.4]
2024-05-31T19:31:35.888420+00:00 a64adacb47b7 postfix/smtpd[139]: disconnect from astuto-web-1.astuto_astuto[172.27.0.4] ehlo=1 auth=0/1 commands=1/2

Astuto is not completing the SMTP process.

Current version: 20240521124018