Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

feature request: Google Assistant Trigger #5

Open
YeonV opened this issue Oct 5, 2020 · 9 comments
Open

feature request: Google Assistant Trigger #5

YeonV opened this issue Oct 5, 2020 · 9 comments
Labels
enhancement New feature or request trigger wanted New trigger request
Projects

Comments

@YeonV
Copy link

YeonV commented Oct 5, 2020

Context

React on commands sent from a google assistant (i.e. home mini)

Alternatives

ifttt -> google assistant

Has the trigger been requested before?

Nope

@YeonV YeonV changed the title Google Assistant Trigger feature request: Google Assistant Trigger Oct 5, 2020
@theowenyoung theowenyoung added enhancement New feature or request trigger wanted New trigger request labels Oct 5, 2020
@theowenyoung
Copy link
Member

Hi, @YeonV , I'm not familiar with google assistant API, do you familiar with the google assistant API? Or, is there webhook supporting?

Is there any examples about using their API to do with this?

Anyway, I'll check it if there is an appropriate way.

Thanks for your advice.

@YeonV
Copy link
Author

YeonV commented Oct 5, 2020

Hey, we could chat via discord maybe?
I did some screenshots for creating this on ifttt:
screens 1-4: trigger
screens 5-8: action
1:
1
2:
2
3:
3
4:
4
5:
5
6:
6
7:
7
8:
8

@YeonV
Copy link
Author

YeonV commented Oct 5, 2020

Maybe this could help:
This is how HomeAssistant integrated this:
https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/google_assistant/

@theowenyoung
Copy link
Member

theowenyoung commented Oct 5, 2020

Thanks @YeonV , we can chat at slack

As you said, I prefer to use the IFTTT applet [Google -> Webhook].

If we developed with Google API, others may need more work to do. Like create their own google project, etc.

The bad thing is, IFTTT now only supports 3 free applet created by user. And we can not publish a general applet at IFTTT, because they don't support webhook as a public applet.

https://help.ifttt.com/hc/en-us/articles/115010230347-Webhooks-service-FAQ

What do you think?

@YeonV
Copy link
Author

YeonV commented Oct 6, 2020

Hey @theowenyoung

I want to get rid of IFTTT completely, since they started with limitations and pricings...
I think if actionflow could have his own google-assistant-trigger, a lot of users would switch to actionflow.

Yesterday i managed to do it via dialogflow, but at the end this is gonna be paid too.

For the beginning one text ingredient would be enough. We could then parse and process the commands on the actions-side (webhook server)

Yes we can talk in slack but your link only links to this issue.
https://join.slack.com/t/neuerworkspac-mgo8135/shared_invite/zt-iadk74ow-iO~RoViJjaTmbvpcZ7D1Rw

@theowenyoung
Copy link
Member

@YeonV I'm sorry, the correct link is https://join.slack.com/t/actionsflow/shared_invite/zt-h5tmw9cn-GbZ4fzU_vc_qB~nnS_2Lvg it's an Actionsflow slack workspace.

I'm afraid that IFTTT google assistant trigger is still the best choice for us, it's a parter of Google Assistant, they have an advanced permission of google assistant.

Maybe we can publish a public applet of [IFTTT google assistant] to slack, then set a Actionsflow webhook at slack? Or, the other relay service at IFTTT.

Public IFTTT applet is still free.

@YeonV
Copy link
Author

YeonV commented Oct 6, 2020

@theowenyoung okay. There is no need in having a public applet, as everything is working already.
Reading the purpose of this project just made me hope, I can finally get rid of ifttt, because I don't like them anymore and have no problems if it takes some more time, setting up some things to have a self-hosted version.
Maybe in the future, if this project grows, it could reach a dev who is able to solve this.

@theowenyoung
Copy link
Member

@YeonV Okay, thanks.

I'll remember this feature request, see if there is a good solution, and then update this issue

@theowenyoung theowenyoung added this to Wait and see in Actionsflow Oct 23, 2020
@maxpd1
Copy link

maxpd1 commented Aug 10, 2022

I am interested in getting rid of IFTTT too as they redesigned the whole Google Assistant integration and made it useless.
How far have we come with actionflows?
The above description is exactly how I use IFTTT too.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
enhancement New feature or request trigger wanted New trigger request
Projects
Actionsflow
Wait and see
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants