"Add Comment for Selected Lines" does not work well

[alexrp]

Example:

If I ask Sidekick to add a comment explaining the selected code, what happens is:

If instead I try this code:

I get:

Which seems to indicate that it is describing the code above.

I get similarly odd results anywhere I've tried this feature. Seems like it could use some love in general.

[kristopax]

Hi. Thank you for reporting this. In regards to the issue of Sidekick commenting about an empty "Section of Interest", we'll try to figure out what's going on there. It's definitely not helpful.

As for the comment that seems to pertain to a different section of code, it's possible that the span of addresses from your selection includes one of the addresses associated with the other section of code. Due to a current limitation in Binary Ninja in getting the exact lines of a code selection, this can happen. Also, is it possible for you to provide another screen shot with addresses displayed? That would help us determine if that's what's going on there.

[alexrp]

Sure, here's one with addresses on:

Also, BNDB is here if needed.